Cordial Deconstruction

Observations from our shared single objective reality in a materialistic, naturalistic, & effectively macro-deterministic universe.

  • Recent Posts

  • Comments Are Welcome

  • Recent comments

    R Johnson on Traces of Liquid Nitrogen
    World marks 50th ann… on World marks 40th anniversary o…
    Karl Withakay on Deconstruction Review of Fring…
    rich on Deconstruction Review of Fring…
    D. Fosdick on My Reflections on Mark Cuban’s…
  • Categories

  • Archives

Archive for the ‘Science’ Category

Deconstruction Review of Fringe, Episode 7 Season 4, Wallflower

Posted by Karl Withakay on November 18, 2011

A Gold/Yellow Episode

As always, an episode synopsis will be found over at Scott’s Polite Dissent

Transfer That Man to the Fringe Division, ASAP!

The officer gets a little spooked, and he discharges the entire magazine of his Beretta 92F with no target in sight and no concern where the bullets might end up.  He’s definitely Fringe material.

Gun Notes

The officer discharged only 4 rounds, which means that starting with one in the chamber, he had only 3 rounds in a 15 round magazine.

Also, the slide did not lock back on the last round like it should have, and the officer pulled the trigger a fifth time on an empty chamber.  Before it was mentioned the he emptied his entire clip (see below on that), I considered the possibility that the fifth round was a dud, and he had not emptied the magazine, but the dialog nixed that possibility.  Perhaps the officer had a low quality magazine with a weak spring and intentionally did not fully load the magazine to prevent over compressing the spring, but if your magazine can’t reliably feed a full load of rounds , it’s a liability and needs to be replaced or resprung.  A weak magazine spring is a common cause of slide lock failures.

Magazine Clippings

A clip is a device (usually a bent strip of metal) that holds rounds of ammunition to facilitate loading certain firearm magazines.  A magazine is a device that holds and feeds ammunition in a gun.  The Beretta 92F has a detachable 15 round box magazine and does not use clips.  Most modern pistols designed after WW I do not use clips at all.

Revisiting White Fright

I’ve covered this before, but despite Walter’s credulity on the subject, fright can not turn hair white.  Hair is not living, and no chemical process in the body can affect its color once it is grown.

Also, I don’t believe fright can make you go albino either.  You can go momentarily pale if the blood flushes from your face, but that’s not the same as loosing your skin pigment, and you really wouldn’t be any paler than your average corpse.  Fright certainly won’t cause your eyes to go red.

If It Bleeds, We Can Kill It

Chromatophores and the animals that have them are pretty cool, but they’re not Harry Potter invisibility cloaks.  They can blend into and with backgrounds, but they cannot become transparent such that you can look right through them.

MayI Please Borrow The Multiverse Manipulator Sometime, Broyles?

Broyles won’t even let Peter walk around in public without an armed escort to limit his interaction with other people.  Does Peter really think they will let him play around with the big, scary machine built to destroy universes?

Quote #1

Walter:

“Tell Broyles, Science has no price tag!”

Wait, What…?

U-Gene originally had a pigment problem, and was treated with chromatophores that made him able to be invisible by dynamically blending in with the environment around him, but he’s not bending light around him like an invisibility cloak would, so he should be creating shadows.  Also, no explanation was giving as to how these cells could accurately reproduce 3D lifelike images in real time capable of making him not noticeable to people looking in his direction, if not right at him.  That’s some major processing power to do that.

Additionally, if his original problem was a lack of pigment, why wouldn’t stealing other people’s pigment be a workable substitute cure (at least in the Fringaverse) in place of the chromatophores?  Yes it was a genetic deformity so I would expect he would need to constantly replenish his pigment, but I don’t see why it would revert him to his original, pre-cure state and kill him

Was He Being Politically Correct?

Why target Caucasians for acquiring pigment; wouldn’t U-Gene have had to kill fewer people if he went after darker skinned people?

Magic UV Light

That mouse didn’t fluoresce under the UV light, it simply became visible as if a normal light was shining on it.  Apparently the super chromatophores absorb UV light and re-emit it at the exact same wavelength of light that would be normally be reflected by normal cells when regular visible spectrum white light shines on them.  Also, apparently U-Gene’s and the mouse’s hair is made up of these chromatophores as it’s also invisible.  I wonder about the mouse droppings.

Bad Plot Convenience Theater

Olivia’s line about the search taking too long and them needing to split up was entirely contrived to separate her on her own; it made no practical sense.

What’s the hurry?  Isn’t a slow, methodical search better?  Why not at least break up into teams of two?  Isn’t it good to have someone backing you up?  If I ran the Fringe division, I’d have a rule:   Always have a partner, and never leave your wingman under any circumstances.  No teams smaller than two people.

Olivia Dunham, Elite Government Agent

Is anybody keeping count of how many times Olivia has lost or carelessly discharged her firearm over the years?

Quote #2

Nina:

“Your life is an experiment.  You have to find out where you belong, find your own place in the world.”

Things We have Learned In This Episode

Massive Dynamic used to be called Kelvin Genetics, and it had an insurance subsidiary called Cypronic Inc.

Nina Sharp in this continuity appears to be evil, though there is good reason to believe she may have been evil in the other continuity as well.

Olivia appears to have a pain killer problem, and she has antibiotics (Ampicillin) in her medicine cabinet.

Olivia and NerdLee may be hooking up at some point.  Obviously there’s a mutual interest there, and Peter seems OK with it, believing that this is not his Olivia.

U-Gene was Experiment 69545

I Will Not Be Pushed, Filed, Stamped, Indexed, Briefed, Debriefed or Numbered. My Life is My Own.

Did anybody else get a little “The Prisoner” vibe at the end there for a moment?  (Skip to the 1 min 50 sec mark if you don’t want to watch the whole video.)

Posted in Fringe, Gold/Yellow Episode, Science, Television | Tagged: , , , | 8 Comments »

Deconstruction Review of Fringe, Episode 6 Season 4, All Those We’ve Left Behind

Posted by Karl Withakay on November 11, 2011

A Gold/Yellow Episode

As always, an episode synopsis will be found over at Scott’s Polite Dissent

 What’s Old is New Again, Again/ A Self Referential Plot Point

I really liked the plot to this episode the first time I saw it, when it was the Window Of Opportunity episode of Stargate SG1.  Sure you can say that story’s plot was derived from and inspired by the movie Groundhog Day, but this episode’s plot was a virtual copy of the plot of Window of Opportunity.  An elite, secret government team comes across a series of time loops/ bubbles that are eventually determined to be caused by a scientist/engineer seeking to reunite himself with his wife who has been lost to him through illness.

But Does it Go to Eleven?

I guess in the new timeline, perhaps Drexler MCD21 Handheld Molecular Cohesion Detectors are widely available.  Even if it isn’t well written, it’s nice that it comes with a real, substantial manual rather than a CD-ROM or just a hyperlink to the website for instructions.

Alpha Radiation 101

Peter:

“If I’m the causing some sort of cosmic disruption, then there’s going to be heightened levels of alpha radiation, but I’m going to need the full spectrum of EM waves, not just the…”

First of all, Alpha radiation is particle radiation (specifically Helium-4 nuclei emitted from atomic nuclei via alpha decay), not electromagnetic radiation or EM waves.  Second of all, based on what science is Peter so sure that his “cosmic disruption” would be causing alpha radiation rather than any other form of radiation, particle or EM?

Peter Bishop Came Unstuck in Time

Peter has a few Billy Pilgrim moments in this episode.

Neutron Radiation 101

Neutron radiation is very penetrating and very hazardous.  It is considered to be the most hazardous form of radiation.  If there was strong enough neutron radiation to cause embrittlement of the metal bumper, it would have been strong enough to kill the passengers and also induce radioactivity in the exposed materials.   Also, Peter is wrong that neutron radiation has to be produced by “human technology”.

-Neutrons are produced from cosmic radiation interacting with the Earth’s atmosphere.

-Neutrons are produced when low Z materials like Beryllium are exposed to alpha particle sources like Radium through α,n nuclear reactions.

-Neutrons can also be produced if a gamma ray photon has an energy exceeding the binding energy of an atomic nucleus and strikes it.

-Neutrons are produced through natural fission.  Sustained natural fission occurred about 1.7 billion years ago in the Oklo natural reactor.

-Very high neutron fluxes are produced in supernova explosions.

Honestly, I didn’t Know this Until I Looked it Up, but…

A Fibonacci spiral is not a perfect golden spiral, though it is an approximation of one and is often confused for one.

Quote of the Show

Walter:

“You can’t just walk from the present into the past, shattering the laws of physics.”

No, of course not..  I mean, it’s perfectly reasonable that you can create a time bubble, shattering the laws of physics, but walk through the time bubble, no that would be laughably ridiculous.

Faraday 101

That was not anything remotely approaching a Faraday cage.  Peter would have to have been nearly fully enclosed in a metal mesh, shell, or foil wrap.  That harness seemed more like some soft of counter field generator rather than a Faraday cage.  Faraday cages protect against electric fields and certain wavelengths of electromagnetic fields.  Are the time bubbles created by EM fields?

How Important is that Right Hand, Peter? (It’s like a Whole ‘Nother Person)

I might have tested my “Faraday Harness” with something other than my right hand.  Maybe my left hand, my left foot, or perhaps a small stick would have been my choice.

Did Walter Invent the Flat Panel TV in 1991?

Why was there a flat panel TV in a house that supposedly hadn’t been occupied for 20 years?

Posted in Fringe, Gold/Yellow Episode, Science, Television | Tagged: , , , , , , , | 20 Comments »

Deconstruction Review of Fringe, Episode 5 Season 4, Novation

Posted by Karl Withakay on November 4, 2011

A Gold/Yellow Episode

As always, an episode synopsis will be found over at Scott’s Polite Dissent

NüFringe Retrocontinuity Clarifications

-Olivia’s mother died when she was young, and she and her sister were raised by Nina Sharp.

-William Bell is still dead.

Cancer 101

I don’t think the writers understand what cancer is.  Cancer is basically a condition of uncontrolled cellular replication.  Malcolm’s research into encouraging cellular replication would be unlikely to have any direct application to cancer treatment except possibly to replace tissue or organs removed by surgery to remove the cancer, but it would not be able to cure malignancies or metastases (kill or eliminate cancer cells).   The problem in cancer is not primarily with replacing tissue; it is with removing the cancerous cells.  The research would be useless in curing cancer.

Mad Scientists Have Ethics?

William Bell, the man who collaborated with Walter in experimenting on children with an experimental, mind altering drug  (Cortexiphan), shut down a project into cellular replication for the purpose of tissue replacement due to ethical concerns?  WTF?

I’m Gonna Need Some Pliers and, uh, a Set of 30-Weight Ball Bearings

That sure was a neat trick where Peter hacked into a Cisco digital phone system just by crossing a few wires.  You can’t hot wire VOIP.

Did Gas Pumps Get Faster and Gas Get Cheaper?

Malcolm spent about 10 seconds pumping gas and the final reading on the pump was $11.16 and 14 gallons (though he paid $20), which puts gas at 79 cents a gallon and the flow rate at 1.4 gallons/ second.  If I’m ever driving in Rutland Vermont, I’ll make sure to fill up at Newhart Gas, where the fuel flows fast and cheap!

Genetics 101

It would take more than a complete copy of a persons’ genome to create an identical copy of that person.  It is often said the genes are the blueprints of an organism, but that’s not quite accurate.  Genes are more like a cross between a blueprint and a building code.  Many factors affect the final product.  In the analogy, available materials, contractors, worker skill & motivation, weather, etc all affect the form of the final product.  For a human being there are likewise numerous environmental factors and inputs that all affect the final product.  Even identical twins do not have identical fingerprints.

When Is a Copy Not a Copy?

Let’s say that the shape shifters used more than just DNA to copy their victims.  Peter stated that they replicate their victims down to the molecular level.  If that were the case, then they would have brains identical to their victims and think, feel, and act just like their victims, unless the data drive over rode the brain to some extent.  Of course, if they were identical down to the molecular level, they would have no interface to the tech.

Cylon Problem

Peter in regards to the enhanced shape shifters assuming the form of anyone they wanted to:

“Short of performing surgery to find those memory disks, you would have no way of knowing”

Really, there are partially metallic, electronic objects located inside these bodies and they can’t be detected by:

-X-Ray

-MRI

-Metal Detector

-EMF Meter?

Further more, they should be able to confirm identity by EEG.  (Fringe has established the ability to identify a persons’ unique brainwave signature)

Think Fast

Seeing as how at the end, Malcolm seemed convinced that Bell was right about his work, why didn’t Malcolm just throw the vial to the ground instead of trying to run away with it?

Shape Shifter 101/ Fool Me Once, Shame on You…

How stupid is Olivia?  I mean, she’s encountered shape shifters before, and she fell for the same trick again!  Did anyone watching not know the wounded agent was likely the shifter right away?  Anytime a hostile shape shifter leaves your sight, assume the next person you encounter is that same shape shifter!  I weep for the safety of our universe.

Posted in Fringe, Gold/Yellow Episode, Science, Television | Tagged: , , , , | 8 Comments »

Deconstruction Review of Fringe, Episode 4 Season 4, Subject 9

Posted by Karl Withakay on October 14, 2011

A Gold/Yellow Episode

As always, an episode synopsis will be found over at Scott’s Polite Dissent

RetroTech

Why did Walter’s super multi-angle photo setup consist pretty much entirely of various models of Polaroid instant cameras, apparently somehow converted to digital?

Magnetic Personality

Walter to Astrid:

“Find anything metal, so they can test whether those objects have become magnetized.”

For any of those objects not made out of ferromagnetic materials, that would indeed be extra Fringe worthy, as only ferromagnetic materials can be magnetized.  Not all metals are capable of being magnetized or attracted to magnets.  Dental amalgam does not contain ferromagnetic materials and is not attracted to magnets.

Bug Out

Mysophobia is the fear of germs and contamination.  Not that it would have eased Walter’s mind at all, but he should have known that urine is generally sterile, and poses little risk of germs.

Wild Wild West

Did the retcon eliminate all the other questionable firearms discharges by Olivia?  Because if not, you’d think they just revoke he firearms privileges by now and take her gun away.

First she blindly shoots out a window with no concern for what’s on the other side of the window, or where the bullet might ricochet to in an urban environment with many hard (ricochet prone) surfaces.  (I watched the scene in slow motion, and though she turns he head towards the window, she covers her eyes with her arms and does not see what’s on the other side of the window, and even if she did see the other side was clear, the ricochet problem still exists.).

Later, in the same episode, she fires her gun at an angle in the air without any concern for where the bullet might land.  (Although the Mythbusters proved you can fire a gun directly vertical with little fear of harm when the bullet lands, any angle will result in a ballistic trajectory and a potentially lethal landing.)  I’m surprised she doesn’t just shoot the bottle caps off of beer bottles and use her gun to turn off the lights like Homer Simpson.

Super Special Magnetic Powers

Not only is Peter’s energy capable of attracting non ferromagnetic metals, it is also capable of unlocking mailboxes in an apartment complex.

Violating Causality

Walter:

“I witnessed effect before cause.”

Effect proceeding cause would appear to violate causality, and would imply faster than light phenomenon/ time travel or retrocausality.  If a particle travels faster than light, it would travel back in time and appear to flow from effect to cause.

Posted in Fringe, Gold/Yellow Episode, Science, Television | Tagged: , , , , , | 1 Comment »

Deconstruction Review of Fringe, Episode 3 Season 4, Alone in the World

Posted by Karl Withakay on October 7, 2011

A Gold/Yellow Episode

As always, an episode synopsis will be found over at Scott’s Polite Dissent

Return of Prop convenience Theater

It sure was handy that the doctor was using a shiny, chrome clipboard so Walter could see Peter in it, wasn’t it?

Fringe Division, Crack Biosafety Unit

Two children die within hours of exposure to an unknown contaminant, probably an unknown pathogen for which no treatment protocol exists and for which the method of transmission is unknown, and nobody examining the scene is in hazmat gear and the bodies are not handled with any precautions whatsoever and just sent to a morgue and a basement lab at Harvard?  This is a textbook case for Biosfety level 4 biocontainment precautions, the highest level there is.  The investigators at the scene should have been in Level A hazmat gear with self contained breathing apparatus and the bodies should have been delivered to a BSL-4 lab with showers, a vacuum room, a UV light room, and other safety precautions designed to destroy all traces of any biohazard as well as have multiple airlocks that are secured to prevent both doors opening at the same time.  Additionally all air and water service going to and coming from a the lab would undergo similar decontamination procedures to eliminate the possibility of an accidental release.

Also, that’s probably not a good time for Nerlee’s likely first biosafety situation.

You don’t Need All the Evidence, Do You?

It’s not like there was any possibility than only one of the bodies would have some important piece of evidence like the method of first transmission of the pathogen or toxin.   Go ahead and save some time and money and only send one to the lab and send the other straight to the morgue.

Quote #1

-written in the kid’s notebook.

“I wonder if I wish my birthday would be just how I dream it”

Lambda Lambda Lambda

A lambda sensor is an actual oxygen sensor.

A Fungus Among Us

Cordyceps are very interesting fungi.  They are all endoparasitoids that prey mainly on insects and arthropods.  They invade and replace host tissue, and some species can even influence host behavior to spread it spores, as with zombie ants.  It’s always more interesting to me when there’s some real, scientific basis for the “science” in Fringe.

Brain Fart

But the part about the fungi forming large neuron like cells to produce a large, thinking brain was just over the top.

In addition to the fundamental absurdity of fungal cells being able to function as neurons, a human brain has about 100 billion neurons in it. If we do some back of the envelope calculations, let’s assume that “neuron” in the lab was typical and was about 4”X4” square (just to speed up and simplify calculations).   If there were just 1 billion of them in Gus’s brain, that would cover approximately 2500 acres of land/surface or about 4 square miles.

All Things Being Equal

This timeline and the old timeline should be identical up to the point that Walter and Peter fell through the ice and the observer did or didn’t save Peter.

Biosafety Level Zero

At least have some Draino ready to pour down the sink if you’re not going to use a BSL-4 lab.

Holy Crap, We’re Doomed (or Doosmed)

It’s unbelievable the amount of caution our Fringe team constantly didn’t take when working around the fungi.  If these people are half of all that stands between two universes and certain doom, the alterverse’s team will need to carry the full burden of saving everything by themselves.

Get A Head

Why bother wearing the fire protection suits when using flame throwers if you’re not going to wear anything on your head?

Ooh, Piece of Candy!

I love that Astrid knows Walter well enough to instantly know he wanted a Popsicle after he mentioned not turning the boy into one and then paused and said “Oh, Astrid…”

Other Options?

I guess it never occurred to Walter to try putting the kid in a medically induced coma or anesthetizing the relevant part of his brain before jumping straight the idea of lobotomizing him?  Presumably it didn’t need to be permanent; he just needed to interrupt the link until the organism was dead.  It’s a good thing he came up with a plan B in time.

Get Him a Red Uniform, Oh, Never Mind, Too Late

I’m guessing I’m not the only one who saw the death of they guy administering the toxin coming, right?

Quote #2

Walter:

“I’ve seen the movie with the talking toys, oddly disturbing.”

Slow Down There, Let’s Not Jump to Any Conclusions

Walter:

“And all this time I thought that I was loosing my mind, that he was a figment of my psychosis.  I’m perfectly sane.”

Maybe he isn’t a figment of your psychosis, but I wouldn’t make any hasty conclusions about the other two parts.

Posted in Fringe, Gold/Yellow Episode, Prop Convenience Theater, Science, Television | Tagged: , , , , , | 6 Comments »

Deconstruction Review of Fringe, Episode 2 Season 4, One Night in October

Posted by Karl Withakay on September 30, 2011

A Gold/Yellow Episode

As always, an episode synopsis will be found over at Scott’s Polite Dissent

Retcon Changes/ Other Universe Details

The other universe’s Broyles (O’Broyles) is now alive, thanks to the Retcon.

Fauxlivia is still with Frank

Lincoln Lee still has the hots for Fauxlivia.

Charlie has hooked up with the hot bug lady.

Fauxlivia presumably has no child that she is aware of.  (I wonder if they’ll address her de-existed child at some point.)

How Do You Define “Mild”?

I don’t consider any sedative that renders you deeply enough unconscious  to be transported to another location without waking to be “mild”.

Iconic Image

I love the obvious homage to the classic ‘80s Maxell Commercial with Walter in the chair behind the speakers listening to loud music.

Wouldn’t It Make a Bit More Sense…

Rather than require Fauxlivia to wear a blond wig for an extended period of time, why not let her come over to our universe to escort Professor McClennan over to the other universe, have Olivia wear a red wig for a shorter period of time, or have a different agent escort him over?

Steak Out

Maybe it’s always been this way, or maybe it’s because of the Retcon, but where we have previously seen canned steak that is kept refrigerated in the alternaverse, now we have Steak dinner frozen meals in cardboard boxes similar to frozen meals here.

A Holmesian Leap of Logic or a House Moment?

OK, from the fact that the guy has 6 frozen steak dinners in his freezer and no food in the fridge, the professor determines that “Dinner is important to him.”, and “He hunts by day.”.  Is he aware that just because the box has the word “dinner” on it, it doesn’t mean you can’t eat it for lunch?  A lot of single guys’ fridges and freezers look a lot like his did; it doesn’t mean that dinner is especially important to them.

Did the Retcon Dumbify the Other Fringe Team?

How did it not occur to anyone that the professor might see something familiar to his life in the killer’s house?  He is after all, sort of the same person.

The Gig is Up

After the professor discovers the truth about the dual universes and Olivias, why does Fauxlivia bother to continue to wear the wig until returning to HQ?

I Know Him Like I Know Myself

Shouldn’t the professor have known what the killer’s reaction was going to be when he confronted him?  Maybe the prof was selfless and did know and hoped it would help the killer be a better person.  Maybe the professor tapped into his darker side and even knew the killer would commit suicide as a result linking with the professor’s mind.

Memories as Vitalistic Essence?

With a computer, when you move a file, you don’t really move the file.  You make a copy in a different location and delete the original file.  Memories are really just data stored in the brain. Either the process of transferring the memory destroys the original memory as a side effect, or the memories have some sort of vitalist essence such that they can be transferred like you move a physical object rather than the way you transfer data.

Obvious Peter Reference

Broyles responding to Olivia in regards to the professor retaining what he learned from Marjorie despite not remembering her,

“At the risk of sounding sentimental, I’ve always thought there were people who leave an indelible mark on your soul, an imprint that can never be erased.”

Posted in Fringe, Gold/Yellow Episode, Science, Television | Tagged: , | 8 Comments »

Deconstruction Review of Fringe, Episode 1 Season 4, Neither Here Nor There

Posted by Karl Withakay on September 23, 2011

A Gold/Yellow Episode

As always, an episode synopsis will be found over at Scott’s Polite Dissent

Opening Theme Fringe Terms

The Fringe terms in the opening theme were:

Existence

Quantum Entanglement

Philosopher’s Stone

Psychometry

Viral Therapy

Ehthereal Plane

Gravitons

Time Paradox

Psychogenesis

Bilocation

Psychic Surgery

Transgenics

Existence, quantum entanglement, viral therapy, transgenics even gravitons aren’t really fringe science, though there could easily be fringe theories and applications of them and gravitons are purely hypothetical as of 2011.  Somehow I doubt this is what they meant by psychogenesis, and I’m wondering if they just thought it sounded fringey or they thought it meant psychic generation of abiogenic life.  I accept time paradoxes as fringe science.  The philosopher’s stone, psychometry, and bilocation are plain pseudoscience or prescience, and psychic surgery is outright fraud.

Continuity Questions

-Did Peter truly never exist at all, or did he die as a child in both universes?

-If Peter never existed at all, why did Walter start all of this if not to travel to the other universe to save Peter?

-What happened to Walter’s wife in this universe’s new continuity?

-How were the machines operated without a Peter or a Peter DNA source?

I’m sure there’s many more questions to be answered that I’m not thinking of off the top of my head.

Night of the Living Dead Pigeons

Is Walter trying to become Herbert West for birds?

Did Astrid back the Car Over Olivia’s Dog During Commercial?

It seems like Astrid is a field agent and Olivia’s partner at the start of the episode, but gets de facto replaced by NerdLee once he shows up at the lab.  My guess is that this will continue in future episodes with Astrid being demoted to Walter’s full time lab assistant from now on.

A Name Worthy of a Poorly Written Comic Book

What do the writers name a commuter that park and rides for her daily commute? Nadine Park, of course.  Why not just go with Carline Park-Ride?

Faith and Reason

NerdLee:

“He believed that everything happened for a reason.  I’m having a hard time believing that there’s a reason for this.”

Everything happens for a reason from the perspective of cause and effect.  The reason something happens is the deterministic cause of that thing.  I believe though, that NerdLee meant that everything happens for a purpose, as in an intentional, directed purpose.  Hey, nobody ever said anything about a good reason or that it has to be good for you.

Heavy Metal Poisoning

Hair loss can be caused by heavy metals like Thallium, Mercury poisoning can damage the kidneys,  and lead poisoning can cause gout.  I had my doubts about gout until I looked it up; you learn something new every day.  Zinc can be toxic in sufficient  amounts, but I don’t think it’s a particularly common problem, although someone apparently once ingested $4.25 in copper plated zinc pennies for some reason and died as a result.

You’re So Transparent

Being transparent sure makes it easier to hit a vein for an injection.  It probably makes a lot of medical diagnostic procedures easy as well as cutting down on radiation exposure  by eliminating a lot of X-rays.

Quote of the Show

Walter:

“People die.  It happens.  Sometimes they die twice.”

The Retcon Hasn’t Made Olivia a Better Agent.

How much closer was Olivia going to get to that suspect before she insisted he turn around, get on his knees, put his hands on his head and interlock his fingers, close enough for him to head butt her?  One episode into the retcon and she’s already been disarmed and nearly killed due to incompetence.

Posted in Fringe, Gold/Yellow Episode, Quotes, Science, Television | Tagged: , , , | 10 Comments »

Deconstruction Review of Fringe, Episode 4 Season 1, The Arrival

Posted by Karl Withakay on June 30, 2011

They were all Blue Episodes back then.

As always, an episode synopsis will be found over at Scott’s Polite Dissent

Not Exactly Formulaic

Technically, what Walter was reciting in bed was the recipe for root beer and not the formula.  A chemical or molecular formula is a way of expressing information about the atoms that constitute a particular chemical compound.  A recipe is a set of instructions that describe the process to make or prepare something.

You are My Density

If that probe really was made of Iridium, it would have been VERY heavy.  Probably too heavy for the flimsy stand used in the lab, and far too heavy for one or two men to move without assistance.  Iridium is the second densest element known, and barely less dense then the densest, Osmium.

Trust Us, It Happened Off Screen Many Times

Olivia about Walter wanting Peter to stay so badly that he’d rather go back to the asylum than loose Peter:

“He would rather go back to St. Claire’s than work here without you.  He’s said that more than once.”

Really?   I don’t recall him saying that on screen.  I could be forgetting it, but I do recall him many times talking about how miserable it was there; I never got the impression he would willingly go back under any circumstances.  It seems more like a contrived plot point by the writers to explain why Peter doesn’t leave.

Ghost Call Log?

If I were in Olivia’s position, and I got a call from what sounded like my dead partner & lover, I’d probably check the call log on my cell phone before bothering to get a trace run.  If the incoming caller ID number showed up, I wouldn’t bother with a  trace; I’d call that number back.  If the call didn’t show up in the call history, then I might get the trace to confirm whether or not a call actually came in.

Also, as a nitpick, Olivia says “I need a call traced from my cell.”  What she needed was a call to her cell traced.

Well, That’s One Thing You Could Call It….

Peter speaking about the probe:

“I sure hope that a gigantic metallic suppository is not the pinnacle of human achievement.”

Well, given the shape and the fact that it vibrates, I can think of something else you might call it….

We’ll Just Pretend it Never Happened/ I Can’t Even Get Out of a Speeding Ticket

I can only wish to ever be so vital or important that people are willing to ignore a crime committed by me as serious as assaulting a federal officer, even if it was against a Junior Agent.

Tough Call

I’m not sure which was worse, the mind reading through nose ports or learning via osmosis.  Neither is worthy of any serious deconstruction.

Digging to China (or Auttrailia)

If the probe burrowed through the Earth and reached the mantle, wouldn’t that create a volcano, or would the magma cool and plug the hole before it reached the surface?

Unanswered Question

Will we find out in season 4 what the heck the probe was, who was after it and why, and why it was important to the Observer?

Posted in Fringe, Science, Television | Tagged: , , | Leave a Comment »

Deconstruction Review of Fringe, Episode 3 Season 1, The Ghost Network

Posted by Karl Withakay on June 23, 2011

They were all Blue Episodes back then.

As always, an episode synopsis will be found over at Scott’s Polite Dissent

Peter’s No Pharmacist

Dextromethorphan is a cough suppressant, Clonazepam is an ant anti anxiety agent, and Fluxetine is Prozac.  None of those drugs is a psychotic.

Solid Science?

The mystery gel (amber) filling a bus from a small delivery container is not so totally far fetched.  Silica aerogel is the world’s lowest density solid, and it has a density (1 mg/cm3) which is slightly less than air (1.2 mg/cm3 at 20ºC and 1 atm).  Aerogel has been nicknamed frozen smoke due to it’s very low density.  A scientist on TV once said that aerogel was as close to nothing as any solid material could be.

Unanswered Questions

Who are the people that Peter was supposed to check with before coming home?  What mystery lies in his past?  Will this mystery be addressed in season four, or will it be forgotten?

Shifting Gears Mid Stride

This is basically a copy-paste of a comment I made on Polite Scott’s site when the show originally aired.

The writers seem to have lost track and veered off in a different path at some point in this episode.  They seem to have switched from the concept of precognitive visions of future events to intercepting communication about plans for future events.  Roy was having visions of these attacks before they happened; not just foreknowledge, but actual, accurate visions of the events. If he was merely intercepting ghost network communication of the plans, he would not see accurate, detailed images of the events before they happen (or even after they happen). You could argue that his brain was interpreting the plans into visual hallucinations, but the show was clearly implying that he was pre-witnessing the actual events, which wouldn’t happen from merely intercepting ghost network communication, unless that communication included streaming video of a detailed computer simulations of the attacks.

Got it Right For the Wrong Reason

Broyles:

“The first responders were worried it was bioterrorism…ghost of the sarin subway incident in Tokyo in 1995.  They called in the CDC…confirmed the attack isn’t biological in nature.  There’s no contagion.”

Sarin gas is a nerve gas chemical weapon; it is not a contagion or a biological weapon.  If the first responders were thinking the incident might be similar to the sarin gas attack on the Tokyo subway in 1995, they should probably have contacted the Army Chemical Materials Agency, not the CDC.

 The Guy’s Got Talent

Unless the ghost network also gave Roy drawing skills, he should try his hand at becoming a comic book/ graphic novel artist.

To Blathe…

Peter about whether Roy is lying or not:

“He’s not.  I’d like to consider myself a fairly good poker player, which requires me to have the ability to read my opponent’s tells, know when he’s bluffing.  He’s not bluffing.”

Peter is describing the process of “reading people” through mental acuity or applied psychology as used in the TV shows The Mentalist and Lie To Me.

Walter’s Idea of Simple…

Walter:

Occam’s Razor.  All things being equal, the simplest explanation is the best.”

Broyles:

“And what is that?”

Walter:

“The man’s psychic.  Theoretically, it’s all quite possible.”

Accepting that psychic powers are theoretically quite possible in Fringe World, the simplest explanation is still that Roy is part of the pattern conspiracy, not that he’s psychic.

Electromagnetic, Particle, or Ocean?

Walter:

“We posited a spectrum of waves lying outside the range of those already discovered.”

It seems like Walter is talking about electromagnetic waves, but to be outside the range of those already discovered, they would have to be beyond gamma rays, which would be very high energy waves and very dangerous.  Perhaps the mysterious waves oscillate into another dimension or universe and thus lie in a spectrum “outside the range” of any already discovered waves.

Organomatallic Magic

Walter regarding the iridium based organomatallic compound that he introduced into Roy’s brain years earlier:

“The compound must have multiplied his bloodstream over time.  Environment, perhaps diet.”

Two problems here.  First, if Walter introduce the compound into Roy’s brain, then it shouldn’t be in his blood stream, unless there was a problem with Roy’s blood brain barrier.  Second, iridium is extremely rare on Earth, 40 times rarer than gold.  How could he get iridium from the environment or diet?  (It’s also not ferromagnetic)

Seeing Should Not Always Be Believing

Walter described the first optical illusion incorrectly.  He stated that the rotary movement gives the impression of  a 3-D tunnel.  In the illusion shown, the rotary motion is the illusion as it is a static image with no motion of any kind.  There’s also no 3-D tunnel effect in this illusion.  Here is the exact image Walter was showing, see for yourself.

Believe it or not, this is a static image.  It’s hard to tell when you look at the whole thing, but if you look close enough at any particular area, you’ll see that no part of the image ever actually changes.

Astrid Farnsworth: Relegated to the Fringe Team For Good Reason

Maybe Astrid should have gotten Roy to sign those release papers before Walter drilled into Roy’s brain.  What would she do if he had said, “Nope, too late.  It’s done, I’m not signing, and I’m suing you, Walter, and the FBI.”?  Even after he signed, a lawyer could argue that due to the experimenting on his brain, Roy was not of sound mind and not capable of entering into a binding legal agreement or legally signing any release of liability.

Posted in Fringe, Science, Television | Tagged: , , , , | Leave a Comment »

Deconstruction Review of Fringe, Episode 2 Season 1, The Same Old Story

Posted by Karl Withakay on June 16, 2011

They were all Blue Episodes back then.

As always, an episode synopsis will be found over at Scott’s Polite Dissent

The Same Old, Flawed Cliché

Where did the mass and nutrients come from for the pregnancy and baby?  The mother did not  consume 20+ pounds of food to provide the needed mass and nutrition for the baby, and the newborn did not consume 100+ pounds of food to provide the mass and nutrition required to grow it’s body to the mass it had when it died.  Plants get the bulk of their mass from carbon extracted from carbon dioxide in the air, but that it a slow process, and it requires energy in the form of sunlight.

First Time In the ER/ Delivery Room?

How hideous was the baby that the ER Delivery Nurse screamed in horror, and the surgeon gagged?

What happened to the Previous Fringe Team?

In the meeting of the Pattern Committee, Nina mentions that she hopes this Fringe/Pattern team will have more successes than the last one.  What happened to the last team?

How Previous Was that Previous Broyles Report?

Nina mentions that in a one of his previous reports, Broyles theorized that Walter’s previous work was the basis for the pattern phenomena.  Is that a previous report as in from last week’s episode when Olivia brought Walter into the Fringe team, or a previous report from before Olivia’s assignment to the Fringe unit?

Keen Eye or Dumb Luck?

Peter discovers “some kind of orange gel” in the hotel and decides he has found something worth sampling, and it does turn out that he’s right, but I’m not convinced it wasn’t just dumb luck.  I mean, orange gel in a bathroom, wow, that must be important.  It couldn’t be liquid hand soap or shampoo, could it?  There’s numerous spots of orange gel in all my bathrooms, and I’m not drugging strippers to steal their pituitary glands, I swear.  Of course, it must be that Peter is so well trained in proper forensic evidence gathering techniques and practices that he knows it’s better to collect a probably useless sample than to ignore a potentially useful one.

This Week’s Darwin Award Goes to….

Victim #2, a stripper who lets a strange, somewhat shifty and agitated man take her to a secluded and fairly abandoned warehouse district for what she believes to be a sexual encounter.  Once in this isolated location, far from the ears of anyone who could hear her scream, she is not the least bit concerned when the stranger tells her to go to the window and look at a bridge, with her back to him.

That Car Was Either Very Well Preserved, or Peter Restored it in Record Time

After 17 years in a dusty garage, that car should have been a bit of a basket case.  The tires should have been flat, and might not have been able to hold air any more.  The battery would have been dead, and probably wouldn’t have held a charge.  The oil and transmission fluid probably would have been partially sludge, and the radiator hose might have crumbled to dust.

Is Astrid an FBI Special Agent or Is she an FBI Special Agent?

Astrid identifies herself as “Junior Agent Astrid Farnsworth”.  I did some searching, and this is the only reference I can find for any use of the term junior agent in the FBI.  It’s a title the FBI gives to kids in a community outreach program.  Entry level agents are just referred to as Special Agents.  Perhaps the junior part is a quasi official term used internally, or perhaps Astrid is just being humored by the real agents.

Living in the Wild, Wild West

The whole part about retrieving the last image seen by the victim was utter nonsense, perhaps worse than the rapid pregnancy mass from nothingness.  Even if we accept the nonsense that the muscle paralyzer somehow froze the neural pathways of the optic nerve, it wouldn’t freeze the electrical impulses that are the image information traveling along that optic nerve.  I was going to speculate on way to make this plot device slightly less execrable, involving “freezing” the sate or the rods and cones of the victim’s eyes, but it’s really not worth it; it’s just a stupid idea in the first place.  How stupid of a plot device is it?  Well, they used in the horrible, awful 1999 movie, Wild Wild West.

I rest my case.

And Then They screw Up the Lame Plot Device

Olivia asks Walter:

“This would be one of the last images she saw?”

Walter responds:

“In theory, yes.”

No, according to Walter’s theory, the neural pathways on the optic nerve are frozen in place by the muscle paralyzer, preserving the absolute last image seen by the victim.  But that’s a problem, because she was looking at her attacker when the paralyzer was administered, so her attacker’s face was the last thing she saw, not the bridge.

Homeland Security or Big Brother?

Olivia:

“I want satellite images of that area for the last 24 hours.”

Does the government really have continuous high resolution satellite imagery being taken of every square foot of every major city in the U.S.?  It’s a good thing it wasn’t a cloudy day.

Safety Is No Accident

Olivia hands her spare Glock pistol to Peter and tells him,

“Safety’s on the right.”

Um, Gock’s do not have a manual safety; the safeties are all passive.  When you pull the trigger, the gun goes bang (if the gun is loaded), just like a typical revolver.

Partially Empty Magazine or Typical Hollywood Shooting Sequence?

After three shots, the slide on Peter’s gun locks back, indicating the gun is out of ammo.  This is fairly typical of shooting sequences in TV and the Movies.  The stunt prop-master typically only loads enough blanks for the number of shots in the scene, and so the last shot in the scene expends the last round in the gun, and the slide locks back because the magazine is empty.  It’s only a mild annoyance, but I wish they would load the magazine with an inert dummy round after the blanks to correct this.

Peter’s First Discharge, No Play On words Intended.

It’s only episode two, and already Peter, a civilian and not even an official FBI consultant yet, has fired Olivia’s weapon in an attempted exercise of leathal force.  The FBI must just hand out guns as party favors, or at least Olivia does.

I’m Not a Doctor, but…

I know from very good authority that you DON’T SHOCK A FLATLINE.

Just Five Minutes

For the sake of science fiction, I will accept the super rapid aging, but why would the existing hair turn gray?  New growth hair might be gray, but the existing hair is not alive and doesn’t turn gray.  Hair on corpses stays the same color, many years after death.  Old wigs made from human hair don’t go gray after many decades of aging.

Does Massive Dynamic Have a Seat On the UN?

Nina states:

“Massive Dynamic is one of the ten largest economic entities in the world.”

I can buy that Massive Dynamic is one of the ten largest corporations in the world, but countries and trading zones count as economic entities, and I think the G8, the G20, and the EU might keep Massive Dynamic out of the top ten.

Fibonacci Foul-up

The first sequence Walter is counting out while trying to fall asleep, 0,1,1,2,3,8,13,21,34,55, is a Fibonacci sequence where each number in the series is the sum of the previous two numbers (after 0 & 1), but he left out the 5 for some reason.  I wonder if that was a Walter error, a John Noble error, or a writers error.

The second sequence Walter counts out is 1,2,33,3,77,2,21,6,110.  Does anybody know what that is supposed to be?

SPOILER ALERT: DON”T READ THIS NEXT SECTION IF YOU DON’T WANT FUTURE EPISODE/ SEASON DETAILS REVEALED 

What happens to the secret Pattern Committee, other than Nina and Broyles?  They’re long gone by seasons 2 and 3.

Why does Nina acts as if she doesn’t personally know Walter when discussing him with the committee?  Is she trying to hide the fact she knows Walter, or had the writers not yet decided that she knew Walter?

As early as episode two, the ground work for Peter’s past and the aleterverse are being established, showing that the show was not being entirely made up as the writers went along.

Posted in Fringe, Science, Television | Tagged: , , , | 3 Comments »